GCRA
OVERVIEW
FAQ
NEWS
ARTICLES
PHOTOS
REEF ISSUES
RESTORATION
PAPERS
LINKS
|
|
|
|
Scientists and Divers Urgently
Petition State of Florida Updated May 10, 2003 TO: Charlie Crist, Florida Attorney General Tom Gallagher, Chief Financial Officer Charles H. Bronson, Agriculture Commissioner David Struhs, Department of Environment Protection, Florida Broward County Commissioners Jim Naugle, Mayor, City of Fort Lauderdale Oliver Parker, Mayor, Lauderdale by the Sea Billy Causey, Superintendent, Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary Dan Basta, Director, National Marine Sanctuaries Program, NOAA Roger Griffis, U.S. Coral Reef Task Force All Members, U.S. Coral Reef Task Force Secretary of Commerce Secretary of Interior Environmental Protection Agency National Marine Fisheries Service NOAA
We, the undersigned coral reef scientists, conservationists, divers, fishermen, and other concerned members of the public, urgently appeal to the US Government, the State of Florida, and Governor Bush to immediately designate the remaining healthy shallow coral reef in Broward County as Outstanding Florida Waters, establish a management plan, and provide the same level of protection as the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary. This coral reef (lying between Lauderdale by the Sea to Port Everglades in Broward County, Florida) is the last North American near shore coral reef still in excellent condition. It is threatened with imminent destruction by the effects of unnecessary dredging and beach filling. The Segment II permit (Permit Authorization #0163435-005-JC) that will allow the destruction of this reef is awaiting a final decision by Governor Bush and the Cabinet of the State of Florida. A hearing is scheduled for January 28 2003. We call for the permit to be denied because it violates Executive Order 13089 (Coral Reef Protection), and common sense. These Florida coral reefs are a priceless national treasure. They are the only healthy coral reefs in North America that one can swim to from the beach, and the only coral reefs directly in front of a major urban area. They represent the only place in Florida that corals and reef fish can spread northward if global warming continues. The Broward County reefs that lie closest to the beach are several miles in length and, amazingly, are covered with between thirty and forty percent of healthy, live coral, including many ancient corals up to a thousand years old. They contain the largest forest of Staghorn coral (a rare and rapidly vanishing species) known to remain in the entire Caribbean reef region. Dense fish populations pack these reefs which are essential habitat for juvenile fish. This nursery will surely perish without protection. These particular reefs are the last known of the once abundant shallow reefs that bordered Southeast Florida. Only by accident have they survived. They lie in front of the only large remaining stretch of Southeast Florida beach not already filled with dredged materials, which killed most of the other shallow reefs in the region. Those old reefs were equally magnificent. But they remain only in the memories of the oldest divers who watched them suffocate and die when dredged mud and sediment washed over them. No assessment studies were done until almost all of these old corals had been killed. It is unthinkable that the State could allow history to repeat itself by permitting the destruction of the last remaining stretch of healthy near shore Florida corals. Incredibly, these threatened Broward County reefs were unknown to scientists until very recently, even though they have been the crown jewel for local divers and fishermen for many years. Because they were unknown, they were never identified as a coral reef habitat, or designated as Outstanding Florida Waters, and have no protected status of any kind. This proposed dredging project is completely unnecessary. There is little beach erosion taking place in the stretch still protected by the living reef. By contrast, in all the areas where reefs were killed by previous beach dredge-filling projects, there is strong beach erosion. Those beaches can be more cheaply re-nourished by bypassing sand blocked by jetties from reaching them than by dredging the last available offshore sand supplies. Dredge fill material will directly bury some 13.6 acres of near shore hard-bottom that are feeding areas for endangered Green Turtles. Supporters of dredging point out that the dredge material will not be deliberately dumped directly on the reefs. But because the reefs lie in only 10-15 feet of water, 150 to 500 yards offshore, the pipelines from the dredge boats must cross them to get to the beach. There have been repeated and inevitable accidents in previous dredging projects as barges, anchors, chains, pipes, and suction pumps have damaged corals, despite the best of intentions. The mitigation plan requires 600 ton capacity barges with a loaded draft of approximately 7 feet to go over the reef to dump 152 million pounds of 4 to 6 foot boulders in the surf zone near the inner edge of the reef. Worse, the reefs will inevitably be smothered by mud plumes from the dredged material that will be re-suspended by wave action for years to come. Coral reefs are the most sediment-sensitive of all marine ecosystems. Staghorn corals, which lie closest to the beach, are the most sensitive species. The turbidity standard that is being applied (29 NTU) in the monitoring plan for this project is many times too high for these corals. This dredging project is as economically wasteful as it is environmentally irresponsible. According to the recent (2001) NOAA Socioeconomic Study of Reefs in Southeast Florida, Broward County earns some 2.069 billion dollars per year from reef related diving, fishing, and other marine activities that employ 36,000 people. This is more than any other Florida county including Monroe County (the Keys) and Dade County (Miami). Each dollar spent to destroy these reefs will eliminate many more dollars per year of income to the people of Broward County. Broward County is the shore diving capital of the continental United States and the only place where healthy coral reefs can be dived or snorkeled to from land. To allow this marvelous marine habitat to be destroyed is unconscionable. To destroy it in the name of widening a beach that is not eroding is like burning down the last Giant Redwood forest in the process of roadside weed clearance. Therefore, we appeal for immediate emergency action to save North America's last healthy near shore coral reefs from imminent threatened destruction. We call on all responsible Florida State, County, and Municipal officials to reject the Segment II dredging permit application and to fulfill the responsibilities designated under Coral Reef Protection Executive Order 13089 to protect all coral reefs in US waters. Further, we call on all responsible State and Federal Agencies to immediately begin the process to designate these reefs as Outstanding Florida Waters, to establish a proper management plan to ensure that they receive the same level of protection as those in the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary, and to save them forever as a unique part of the natural heritage of the American people. For more information see the Cry of the Water and Global Coral Reef Alliance report. "Broward County Reef Threatened by Dredging" at www.cryofthewater.org and at www.globalcoral.org. For a video showing the incredible corals and fish of this area contact: Dan and Stephanie Clark at Reefteam2@yahoo.com or 954-753-9737 or 954-298-9737 For more information on the scientific and environmental condition of these reefs contact Dr. Thomas Goreau at goreau@bestweb.net or 617-864-0433.
SIGNATORIES: Cry of the Water Dan Clark, President, Cry of the Water, P.O. Box 8143, Coral Springs, FL 33075 Stephanie Clark, Treasurer, Cry of the Water, P.O. Box 8143, Coral Springs, FL 33075
Global Coral Reef AllianceThomas J. Goreau, Ph.D., President, Global Coral Reef Alliance, 37 Pleasant St., Cambridge, MA 02139 Jeff Houdret, Global Coral Reef Alliance, 324 Richardson Rd., Lansdale PA 19446 James Cervino, Global Coral Reef Alliance, 117-20 5th Ave., College Point NY 11356
Sierra ClubDave Raney, Chair, Sierra Club National Marine Wildlife and Habitat Committee, 1621 Mikahala Way, Honolulu, HI 96816-3321 Public Employees for Environmental ResponsibilityDan Meyer, General CounselChuck Sultzman, Marine Biology Consultant Save Our ShorelineBrenda Lee Chalifour, Esq., Pro Bono for Save Our Shoreline, Inc.
Reef ReliefDee Von Quirolo, Executive Director of Reef Relief, Key West, FL
Greater Ft. Lauderdale Dive AssociationJeff Torode, President, Greater Ft. Lauderdale Dive Association, P.O. Box 460216Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33346
PADIBob Harris, PADI (Professional Association of Dive Instructors)
PADI Project AwareKristin Vallette, PADI Project Aware
Coast AllianceDawn Hamilton, Executive Director, Coast Alliance, 600 Pennsylvania Ave., SE Ste.340, Washington, DC 20003 Reef CheckGregor Hodgson, Director, Reef Check Foundation, 1362 Hershey Hall, 149607, University of California, Los Angeles, CA 90095-1496
Audubon Society CORALationsMary Ann Lucking, Director, Coralations, P.O. Box 750, Culebra, PR 00775
Green Party
South Florida Reef Research TeamDavid Kaplan, Director, South Florida Reef Research Team, Inc., 410 SE Naranja Ave. Port Saint Lucie, FL 34983
Kuyuba Dive ClubAndrew F. Thomas, Board Member, Kayuaba Dive Club
Surfrider FoundationCynthia Guerra, Executive Director, Tropical Audubon Society, 5530 Sunset Drive, Miami 33143 OthersLes Kaufman, Boston University Marine Program, 5 Cummington Street, Boston, MA 02215 Brian Lapointe, Senior Scientist, Division of Marine Science, Harbor Branch Oceanographic Institution, 5600 US 1 North, Ft. Pierce, Fl 34946 Phillip Dustan, Ph.D., Department of Biology, College of Charleston, Charleston, SC 29424 Heinrich Holland, H.C. Dudley Research Professor, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA Mark D. Spalding, PhD, Author, World Atlas of Coral Reefs, Senior Consultant, UNEP World Conservation Monitoring Centre, UK, Research Associate, University of Cambridge, UK James S. Wang, Dept. of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Harvard University, Pierce Hall, 29 Oxford Street Cambridge, MA 02138 Leah Oliver, Research Aquatic Biologist, U.S. EPA Gulf Ecology Division, 1 Sabine Island Drive, Gulf Breze, FL 32561 Piet Verburg, Biology Department, University of Waterloo, 200 University Avenue West, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada N2L 3G1 Jim Higgins, Commercial lobster fisherman, Pompano Beach, FL Julian Sprung, Two Little Fishies and Ricordea Publishing, 4016 El Prado Blvd. Coconut Grove, FL 33133 Tod Mesirow, Director, writer, producer, Way Fun Productions, Los Angeles, California Carol Wilhems, Marketing Specialist for FL Hospitality and Tourism, Hollywood, Fl USA Rikki Grober-Dunsmore, Marine Ecologist, Virgin Islands Biosphere Reserve, 100 Cruz Bay Creek, St. John USVI, Biological Resources Division/USGS, Gaineville, Fl 33653 Brandon Meadows, 344 Guy Strickland Rd, Crawfordvile, FL 32327 Matthew Barton, Florida Atlantic University, 6114 Woodbury Road, Boca Raton, FL 33433 Benjamin Cuker, Ph.D. Professor of marine Science, Hampton University, Hampton VA 23668 Peter J. Auster, Ph.D., National Undersea Research Center, Univ. of Connecticut at Avery Point,1080 Shennecossett Rd. Groton, CT 06340-6048 Rod Fujita, Environmental Defense, 5655 College Avenue, Oakland, CA 94618
Tim McClanahan, Coral Reef Conservation Project, P.O. Box 94470, Mombasa, Kenya
Ronnie Brereton-Stiles (WWF-Green Trust Project Leader) Manzengwenya, South Africa
Kathleen Reaugh (PEW Fellowship Program Biodiversity Researcher), kreaugh@mweb.co.za Gugu Zama (WWF-Green Trust project leader) Manzengwemua, South Africa
Please send names, affiliations, emails, and addresses of signatories to Reefteam2@yahoo.com, or Cry of the Water P.O. Box 8143 Coral Springs, FL 33075
May 05, 2003 Janet Klemm
Environmental Specialist
Fl. Department of Environmental Protection
2600 Blair Stone Rd., MS 3560
Tallahassee, FL 32399-2400
Ph: 850/245-8427 AUTOTEXTLIST Dear Ms. Klemm, Please recognize this letter as an official request to accept our petition as a petition to the State of Florida to designate the area of the Atlantic Ocean off the coast of Broward County Florida from Port Everglades north to Commercial Blvd Pier, from the beach out to a dept of 100 feet as Outstanding Florida Water. We will be sending you a packet of materials to help in the application process.
AUTOTEXTLIST Sincerely, Stephanie Clark Treasure, Cry of the Water
|
|