GCRA  OVERVIEW  FAQ  NEWS  ARTICLES  PHOTOS  REEF ISSUES  RESTORATION  PAPERS  LINKS 

 

 

SEDIMENTATION

Introduction
The earliest coral reef researchers recognized that coral reefs were strongly inhibited wherever muddy freshwater enters the sea by realizing that gaps in continuous fringing and offshore reefs faced the river mouths. Negative impacts of rivers include effects of freshwater and sediments. Freshwater can cause tissue bleaching, but excessive sediment smothers and kills coral tissue and reduces light levels and food supplied to the coral by symbiotic algae. Corals differ greatly in their ability to resist sedimentation, with most species being highly intolerant of even small amounts while a minority are able to tolerate extremely muddy conditions, and a few are even able to live directly in muddy bottoms. The sediment tolerant corals are able to push sediment off their surface through a variety of mechanisms, but these all require expenditure of metabolic energy and when sedimentation is excessive they eventually reach the point where they can no longer spare the energy to keep themselves clean, and the affected tissue dies back.

Effects
The effects of sediment have greatly accelerated with regard to freshwater for two reasons. First is expanded coastal dredging to clear harbors and and provide beach sand and fill, which generates huge muddy plumes in reefs which had formerly had clear water. Second is increasing deforestation of coastal watersheds, causing tremendously increased soil erosion from hillsides. Depending on rainfall, topography, geology, soil types, and land management, deforestation can result in up to thousand-fold increases in sedimentation in near shore waters. As a result sedimentation is taking a severe toll on almost all reefs near continental coastlines and islands, unless they are exceptionally flat or extremely dry.

Sediment damage has a very long lasting impact because mud settles out and is re-suspended many times before it leaves the reef. The original plume will continue to act long after it seems to have disappeared, because mud will be re-stirred by every storm, causing clouds of sediment to slowly and episodically work their way down coastlines, damaging reefs many times more before they are washed away. The effects are severe around reefs of Central and South America, South East Asia, East Africa, and high islands throughout the Pacific, Indian Ocean, and Caribbean.

Classic studies of the impact of sedimentation on coral reefs include the work of Jorge Cortes in Costa Rica, Gregor Hodgson at El Nido, Palawan Island, the Philippines, and Tim McLanahan and David Obura in East Africa. GCRA has not done studies specifically focused on sedimentation, and urges those researching these effects in more detail to check the papers mentioned above. GCRA has taken video of sediment impacted reefs which will be added to this web site later this year, to allow comparison of normal and sediment damaged reefs.

Assessment
Quantitative assessment of sedimentation is always difficult because sediment concentrations and settling rates are extremely variable, depending on the detailed history of rain, wind, and waves at each site. One popular approach is to put out settling tubes, vertically oriented cylinders from which trapped material is periodically collected and weighed. The problem is that what is caught depends on the water energy immediately before, since sediment settles in and is repeatedly resuspended. Tremendous variability of such measurements means vast amounts of data must be collected before average values or trends in them can be meaningfully estimated. Most studies often do not have time, resources, or people for the measurements to cut through the inherent data scatter and noise, and may often be collecting numbers from which little useful conclusions about trends can be drawn.

We favor simpler approaches because such measurements, while useful, can be tediously slow and prohibitively expensive to reach meaningful conclusions. In our view the best proof that sediment is affecting reef health is to look at the proportion of dead coral and living coral tissue covered with fine sediment. Studies should be carried out year round because sediment plumes are highly episodic, linked to dredging, storm, or rain flood events and variations in wave energy and direction. However it is very rare that the relative importance of sediment covering live coral cannot be readily seen, and so recording sediment cover of corals wherever it is significant should be an important part of any reef assessment.